An Elf and a Ranger were camping out in Eriador one night. As they lay in their blankets, the Elf nudged the Ranger and said, […]
Continue readingAuthor: Michael Martinez
Politics: Just Politics
The conflicts between various Númenorean factions can be portrayed as clashes between conservative and liberal elements. Is there sufficient evidence to deduce what went wrong […]
Continue readingThe French Connection
Why did Tolkien use the word ‘corsair’ for his pirates? He needed special pirates with a storied history as rich and detailed as Middle-earth itself. […]
Continue readingWhat Do We Know About The Dwarves Of Dunland?
Q: What Do We Know About The Dwarves Of Dunland? ANSWER: Lindis left this comment in October 2018: “Any thoughts about the existence of a […]
Continue readingHobbitry-in-Armchairs: Philandering Tolkien’s Philology
An armchair investigation of tongue-in-cheek or pen-in-hand Biblical passages which might have, could have, would have, never did, and may still be influencing Tolkien preternaturally, […]
Continue readingPedo Barbarians A Minno
Why are there no barbarians in Middle-earth? Are they too mundane for a heroic age or too simple for a complex world? What is a […]
Continue readingQuestions About Tharbad
Q: Questions About Tharbad ANSWER: People have asked many questions about Tharbad. And while I’ve written a few articles about the city, I haven’t been […]
Continue readingWaiting for a King Like You
Why did the line of the High Kings of Arnor and Gondor come to an early end with the death of Eärendur? Tolkien offers us […]
Continue readingHow Did Middle-earth Realms Fund Their Governments?
Q: How Did Middle-earth Reams Fund Their Governments? ANSWER: I have blended several questions people have asked me (and asked openly on the Web). To […]
Continue readingDid Glóin Imply He Had Met Legolas?
Q: Did Glóin Imply He Had Met Legolas? ANSWER: Peter Jackson’s inclusion of Legolas in the ‘Hobbit’ films continues to weigh on the thoughts many […]
Continue readingWhy Didn’t The Dwarves All Arrive Together In ‘An Unexpected Party’?
Q: Why Didn’t The Dwarves All Arrive Together In ‘An Unexpected Party’? ANSWER: This is a question that someone asks every few years. It was […]
Continue readingWhy Did Elrond Stay In Middle-earth After The Second Age?
Q: Why Did Elrond Stay In Middle-earth After The Second Age? ANSWER: I received this question in July 2024: Why do you think Elrond stayed […]
Continue readingWhat Professions Did Tolkien’s Dwarves Actually Practice?
Q: What Professions Did Tolkien’s Dwarves Actually Practice? ANSWER: An online fan asked if Dwarves do anything other than “mining and smithing” in Tolkien’s stories. […]
Continue readingWhy Would Galadriel Have Allowed Sauron To Stay In Eregion?
Q: Why Would Galadriel Have Allowed Sauron To Stay In Eregion? ANSWER: This question is not connected with Amazon’s Rings of Power show. A Tolkien […]
Continue readingIf Sauron Controlled The Orcs, Why Didn’t They All Get Along?
Q: If Sauron Controlled The Orcs, Why Didn’t They All Get Along? ANSWER: This is an amalgam of several questions people have asked through the […]
Continue readingWas J.R.R. Tolkien Woke?
Q: Was J.R.R. Tolkien Woke? ANSWER: I saw someone drop a comment on social media to the effect of “at least Tolkien isn’t woke”. That’s […]
Continue reading